Friday, 9 September 2016

OROP: Stop the Circus, the Soldier Is Not a Fool

Friday, September 09,2016
NEW DELHI: The former Justice LN Reddy Commission (henceforth refered as ‘RC’ – for Reddy Commission) looking into anomalies, post issue of the Central Government Notification of One Rank One Pension (OROP) on November 7, 2015, interacted with military veterans at Dehradun on September 6, 2016. It is not known whether the RC still is one man commission as announced in the beginning because Dehradun media mentioned serving military officers as part of the Commission – probably misreported?
As mentioned by the media, Reddy interacted with veterans at the Rashtriya India Military College where he informed the audience about his participation in the Char Dham yatra to four pilgrimage sites, and expressed his gratitude to Devbhoomi saying, “It is my personal feeling that the central government was to rethink on issues relating to the anomalies of OROP”.

 The pay and pension of Armed Forces personnel was governed by a separate Pay Commission and OROP was in vogue from 1947 to 1973, with the pension at 70% of the pay and automatic yearly actualization. According to the Koshiyari Committee, OROP implies uniform pension be paid to military veterans retiring in the same rank with the same length of service, irrespective of their date of retirement; any future enhancement in the rates of pension to be automatically passed on to the past pensioners; and bridging the gap between the pension of the current and past pensioners as also future enhancements of pension automatically granted to past pensioners.

Even the na├»ve can interpret that this implies yearly actualization of pension, not every five years which the government announced – amounting to one rank different pensions. Not only was this definition accepted by two Parliaments, it was endorsed in writing by MoD on 26 February 2014. 

The Koshiyari Committee had veritably lambasted the government and bureaucracy, pointing out there was no reason for a 3rd CPC to take an ex-parte decision against OROP, that had been working satisfactorily for 26 years. The Committee also tore through explanations given by the Ministry of Defence, terming the treatment of military veteran’s as a clear case of “Bureaucratic Apathy”. 

Further, the Committee categorically ruled out equating civilian government employees with soldiering because: soldiers retire by rank, not age; terms and working conditions of the armed forces are tougher and harsher;the risk to the life of a soldier is always higher as they work under severe strain with undefined and unlimited working hours; transfers and dislocation along with bleak career prospects are other disadvantages faced by the armed forces; family life in the military is also non-comparable with that of civilian Government employees. 

With the Reddy Commission, attention was successfully diverted from the unaddressed anomalies of the 6th CPC and all preceding CPCs. The 7th CPC adroitly brought the military below the police force and post protests and representations, ‘equated’ the military with the police force which anyway was their intention in the first place. And why should it matter if the police now wears the same ranks, along with the same uniforms and accoutrements? Perhaps tomorrow the task of ‘external defence’ and ‘internal defence’ may become interchangeable. The fallout may be that while we don’t know whom to talk to in Pakistan, Pakistan too would be kept guessing whether they would be confronted by our police or our military. The Chinese may be so dumbfounded that they might withdraw from POK, Shaksgam and Aksai Chin. The dilemma would be for our youth whether they should opt for the olive green or the khakhi, with someone having refashioned the motivating slogan – “Do you have it in you? If you stay in Fauj, no promotion for you. If you continue, no NFU for you. If you leave and go, no OROP for you. Do you still have it in you?” 

But puns and fun apart, the government should seriously stop these sic politico-bureaucratic anti-soldier exercises. The soldier understands everything and he will not start stone-pelting to make you run around in circles. If you can’t fight “bureaucratic apathy” (as pointed out by the Koshiyari Committee) because of your own infirmities, stop wasting money on a circus like RC. If you do not want to give the soldier his due – just say so and he will accept it. This bit about no money ‘only in case of soldiers dues’ doesn’t gel with the din of skeletons vying to pop out of cupboards. 

India always had enough money that was grossly mis-utilized – and this is not just about a Rs 1 crore samosa party or Rs 14 crore spent on the spouse of a politico for medical treatment abroad. OROP has been deliberately portrayed as an officer-related issue, which it is not, affected officers being just 1%. The difficulty of visualizing how military values ‘izzat’ is well understood because no ward of a politician or bureaucrat joins the military but it should suffice to understand it cannot be haggled with as traders do for money. 

Finally, the Mathur-types who are not even authorized to mention ranks post retirement, they would do well to tread carefully when playing with the ‘izzat’ of the soldier and use only their mouths when speaking on the issue in public. (Lt General P.C.Katoch (retired) is a veteran officer of the Special Forces)


  1. What is the use of playing flute in front of deaf donkeys?
    Whatever is our fate,we shall accept it because we are the most obedient and disciplined soldiers in the world.

    1. Naginder singh parmar10 September 2016 at 00:38

      That is the main hinderance
      Pkiticians likes hartals
      And bandjs

  2. Vaddiraju Vijaya Rao9 September 2016 at 09:46

    Enter your comment...G E sir. All Retired Military personnel are expecting a good jump in pension and optimastically hoping that all the anomalies will be resolved favourably.But this delay is testing the patience and giving scope for speculation and I see most of the ex servicemen are demoralised.I do not have any further comment .

  3. Naginder singh parmar9 September 2016 at 21:46

    Let Brigd. and above share a collective
    Dias at JANTAR MANTAR and guide PBORs
    for further struggle or any other
    Path which leads to success.

  4. Political leadership is the chief culprit in frustrating the armed forces persons and Whereas the bureaucracy is playing the games but a sincere political leadership can always show the bureaucracy their true place.LEKIN, HAR SHAKH PE ULLU BAITHA HAI, ANJAME GULISTAN KYA HOGA.....

  5. Why not further comment, comments should be more and more, no one will hear us.

  6. Yes! games and circus ,going on & on.

  7. What will be the disability pension in the 7th pay commission?what is slab system? and when we will receive it

  8. FERNANDO, EX AIRMAN10 September 2016 at 10:07

    As an Airman I have worked under Maharaja’s Grand sons in 60s.I have also seen A maharaja’s Son living in my Station with family.
    My engineering Officer a top university rank holder Now what is the condition? Will you ask your son to join. Military?
    Great days all gone. Let us not live in fools paradise.

  9. Sab ko parade ground mein line mein kada karke goli maro

  10. very good article. Out Genarals should give the feed backs
    like this so that the Politicians and the public will come to know the difficulties and value of the soldiers.
    sgt.S.kanthiah, veteran

  11. Latch Saab has hit the bull's eye. Every sentence is true without any imaginary words. If Modi Saab reads this, he may take some action. Pray to almighty to give some good sense to all concerned.

  12. Our genetal is saying right if you donot want to give orop k?ndly refused we were accepted but donot make a fool in this time every body know your politics