Jethmalani to fight legal battle on OROP issue

 

"I am 93-years-old and I can die any day but I assure you that it will not happen before I get you justice from Supreme Court," he said.

Senior Supreme Court lawyer Ram Jethmalani today assured the ex-servicemen demanding “complete implementation” of ‘One Rank One Pension’ that he will lead their legal battle in the apex court.

“I am 93-years-old and I can die any day but I assure you that it will not happen before I get you justice from Supreme Court,” Mr. Jethmalani said while addressing armed forces veterans staging protest at Jantar Mantar in the national capital.

Major General (retd) Satbir Singh, leader of the protesting veterans, claimed that a case would be filed by Mr. Jethmalani on the OROP demand in the Supreme Court in the next 3-4 days and that Mr. Jethmalani would not charge any fee.

Mr. Jethmalani, who has been fighting a legal case over the issue of black money in SC since 2009, also lashed out at the Narendra Modi government for “failing” to bring back black money stashed away abroad.

“Modi promised to bring back black money from foreign countries and I believed him but he fooled me. But when German government offered to disclose the names of such bank account holders, no one from India approached it,” he claimed.

Singh said four more cases have been filed in the armed forces tribunal.

“These cases pertain to rulings for Jawans, war widows, arrears since 2006, payments for honourary ranks, rounding off of disability pension, and payments of reservists,” he said.

The veterans’ protest at Jantar Mantar entered its 320th day on Friday.

Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar had in September last year announced implementation of the long delayed OROP for ex-servicemen but the veterans have been continuing with their protest demanding “complete” implementation of the scheme.

DENIAL OF OROP TO RESERVIST PENSIONERS-TRIBUNAL ISSUES NOTICE TO MOD

The Armed Forces Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, has issued notice to the Ministry of Defence on a petition challenging the notification issued by the Ministry regarding the one rank one pension (OROP) on February 3, 2016.

The petitioners contend that para 4.1 of the notification deprives reservist pensioners /DSC Pensioners and those who are in receipt of two pension and many other categories from the benefits of one rank, one pension from July 1, 2014, which is illegal, discriminatory, arbitrary, resulting in violation of the Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution and infringement to the Right to Property .

The Bench of the AFT consisting of Justice Parkash Krishna and Lt Gen DS Sidhu ( Retd) issued notice for July 4, 2016, to the Ministry of Defence.

The petitions were filed by the chairman of the All-India Ex-servicemen Welfare Association, Bhim Sen Sehgal, on behalf of the petitioners Baldev Singh, Raghuvir Singh, Bhuri Singh, Raj Mal, Chand Kishore Sharma and many others reservist pensioners, DSC pensioners, as well as those drawing two pensions but deprived of the one rank one pension from July7, 2014.

The association has demanded setting aside of the portion of the notification and direction to the authorities for the grant of OROP to all categories of personnel, including the reservist pensioners, DSC pensioners and those drawing two pensions and the pensions of all these categories be revised from July 1, 2009, September 24, 2012 and then from July 1, 2014, onwards and all arrears be paid to them with interest and exemplary damages.

Sehgal, who appeared for the (PBORs) submitted before the Bench that these reservist pensioners of the Indian Army had served during emergencies of the Indo-China Aggression of 1962, Indo-Pak War of 1965 and 1971 and on completion of their regular and reserve service of 15 years were granted the reservist pension of Rs 40 pm in 1972 which was revised to Rs. 375 pm from January 1,1986, then Rs1,275 pm from January 1,1996 and then Rs 3,500 pm w.e.f January 1, 2006, but thereafter there was no increase in their pension from July, 2009, September 24, 2012, and then from July 1, 2014 (on OROP). The association had already submitted representation to the authorities concerned but nothing has been done till date, hence the association moves the Armed Forces Tribunal for the relief to these unfortunate soldiers who are in advance stage of their life

REPLY RECEIVED FROM DESW THAT THEY ARE ON THE JOB

On 04/24/16 07:31 PM, Santosh Kumar Singh <santosh2002@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear Ma'am

With reference to our earlier meeting in your chamber where I represented the case of delinking 33 yrs condition due to various court rulings but you mentioned that since rule of 33 yrs is not yet abolished by Pension department (DoPPW), you can not issue any such instruction. At the same time you had informed us that as soon as Department of Pension of GOI issue any letter in this regard, you will immediately take the cognizance of report and issue the letter for defence personnel also.

Now that department of Pension & Pensioner's welfare, Ministry of Personnel, PG & Pension  (GOI) have issued the letter no. 38/73/08-P & PW(A) dated 6-Apr-16 regarding delinking of 33 yrs condition, we are eagerly waiting letter from MoD (DESW) and we all request you to take all initiative in issuing the letter as early as and as previously informed to us.

Regards

​Santosh K Singh

Ex Petty Officer

General SecretarY
AFVAI 

REPLY
 From: "K Damayanthi" <jsesw@nic.in>
Date: Apr 24, 2016 22:03
Subject: Re: Issuance of MoD letter on De-Linkng of 33 Yrs Condition for Defence Personnel
To: "Santosh Kumar Singh" <santosh2002@gmail.com>
Cc: "R.K. Arora" <us-pen-legal2@desw.gov.in>, "Shr T.R Singal" <ds-pension@desw.gov.in>
Dear Shri Santosh Kumar ji,

We have received the copy and requested CGDA to send the DGL.

It will be at the earliest.

with regards,

yours sincerely,

K.Damayanthi

  On 04/21/16 08:23 AM, Diwan Singh <diwan.neera@yahoo.com> wrote:

Dear Madam,

we are very delighted to know that you have been at the forefront for championing the causes of welfare of retired soldiers and what impresses us your prompt reply to our genuine requests forwarded to you either through mail or by post. Again we request your goodself to consider our request to let us know the time by which orders from MOD are likely to be issued on delinking of 33 yrs of service for full pension issued by DOPT on 06.04.2016.

  It would not be out of place to apprise your goodself that nearly all the Departments of Indian Govt except MOD have issued orders for compliance of the above orders. Kindly let us hear from you the expected date of issuance of these orders.

Thanks

Diwan singh

 REPLY

 From: K Damayanthi <jsesw@nic.in>
To: Diwan Singh <diwan.neera@yahoo.com>
Sent: Sunday, April 24, 2016 10:40 PM
Subject: Re: The latest OM dated 06.04.2016 issued by DOPT on delinking 33 years of service for full pension

we have initiated the process. we will do at the earliest.

 

 

A GLANCE AT PRE-REVISED SCALE & REVISED PAY IN THE PAY BAND

Sergeant (Group - X)

Pre-revised scale : 5000 - 100 - 6500
Revised Pay Band PB-1 + Grade Pay + MSP + X Group Pay : 5200 - 20200 + 2800 + 2000 + 1400

Pre-revised Basic Pay	Revised Pay
Pay in the scale	Pay in the Pay Band	Grade Pay	Military Service Pay	X Group Pay	Total Revised Pay
5000	9300	2800	2000	1400	15500
5100	9490	2800	2000	1400	15690
5200	9680	2800	2000	1400	15880
5300	9860	2800	2000	1400	16060
5400	10050	2800	2000	1400	16250
5500	10230	2800	2000	1400	16430
5600	10420	2800	2000	1400	16620
5700	10610	2800	2000	1400	16810
5800	10790	2800	2000	1400	16990
5600	10980	2800	2000	1400	17180
6000	11160	2800	2000	1400	17360
6100	11350	2800	2000	1400	17550
6200	11540	2800	2000	1400	17740
6300	11720	2800	2000	1400	17920
6400	11910	2800	2000	1400	18110
6500	12090	2800	2000	1400	18290

Sergeant (Group - Y)

Pre-revised scale : 4320 - 85 - 5595
Revised Pay Band PB-1 + Grade Pay + MSP : 5200 - 20200 + 2800 + 2000

Pre-revised Basic Pay	Revised Pay
Pay in the scale	Pay in the Pay Band	Grade Pay	Military Service Pay	Total Revised Pay
4320	8040	2800	2000	12840
4405	8200	2800	2000	13000
4490	8360	2800	2000	13160
4575	8510	2800	2000	13310
4660	8670	2800	2000	13470
4745	8830	2800	2000	13630
4830	8990	2800	2000	13790
4915	9150	2800	2000	13950
5000	9300	2800	2000	14100
5085	9460	2800	2000	14260
5170	9620	2800	2000	14420
5255	9780	2800	2000	14580
5340	9940	2800	2000	14740
5425	10100	2800	2000	14900
5510	10250	2800	2000	15050
5595	10410	2800	2000	15210

Public Notice for addressing anomalies on One Rank One Pension

F. No. 12(39)/2015/D(Pen/Pol)(Part-V)

Ministry of Defence

Department of Ex-servicemen Welfare

D(Pension/Policy)

New Delhi, Dated 13.04.2016

Public Notice for addressing anomalies on One Rank One Pension (OROP)

Government of India, Ministry of Defence, Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare vide notification No. 12(1)/2014/D(Pen/Pol)/Part-II dated 07.11.2015 issued orders for implementation of One Rank One Pension (OROP) scheme for Defence pensioners. Detailed implementation orders of OROP with 101 tables containing revised pensions of different ranks and categories have also been issued by MoD, DESW vide order No. 12(1)/2014/D(Pen/Policy)-Part-II dated 03.02.2016 and uploaded on the website of DESW at www.desw.gov.in. The Pension Disbursing Agencies (PDAs) have been authorized to carry out revision of pension of pre 1.7.2014 pensioners drawing pension as on 1.7.2014 in terms of MoD order dated 3.2.2016 with applicable rates of Dearness relief without calling for any applications from the pensioners and without any further authorization from the Pension Sanctioning Authorities concerned.

2. All affected Defence Forces pensioners of various categories, Pensioners’ Association and all concerned authorities are requested to take note of these orders for their information and further necessary action.

3. In order to take cognizance of anomalies that may arise in implementation of OROP orders, its implication on service matters including inter-services issues, Government has appointed a one-member Judicial committee headed by Justice L. Narasimha Reddy, retired Chief Justice of Patna High Court vide MoD notification No. 12(01)/2014-D (pen/Pol)-Part¬II dated 14th December, 2015.

4. Defence Forces pensioners/family pensioners, Defence Pensioners’ Associations can submit their representation, suggestions/views on the revised pension as notified under above orders, to the MoD, DESW through post or by email at addresses mentioned below by 29th April 2016

Postal Address: Under Secretary/D(Pension/Policy)

Room No. 220A, B’ Wing

Sena Bhawan, New Delhi-110011

Email ID:us-pen-pol@desw.gov.in

OM ISSUED FOR 50% PENSION FOR LESS THAN 33 YEARS

No. 38/37/08-P&PW (A)

Government of India

Ministry of Personnel, PG & Pensions

Department of Pension & Pensioners' Welfare

3rd Floor, Lok Nayak Bhawan

Khan Market, New Delhi-ll0 003.

Dated the 06th April, 2016

OFFICE MEMORANDUM

Sub:- Revision of pension of pre-2006 pensioners – de inking of revised pension from qualifying service of 33 years.
The undersigned is directed to say that as per Para 4.2 of this Department's OMof even number dated 1.9.2008 relating to revision of pension of pre-2006 pensioners w.e.f 1.1.2006, the revised pension w.e.f. 1.1.2006, in no case, shall be lower than 50% of the sum of the minimum of pay in the pay band and the grade pay thereon corresponding to the pre-revised pay scale from which the pensioner had retired. A clarification was issued vide DoP&PW OM of even number dated 3.10.2008 that the pension calculated at 50% of the minimum of pay in the pay band plus grade pay would be calculated at the minimum of the pay in the pay band (irrespective of the pre-revisedscale of pay) plus the grade pay corresponding to the pre-revised pay scale.
2. Several petitions were filed in the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi inter alia claiming that the revised pension of the pre-2006 pensioners should not be less than 50% of the minimum of the pay band + grade pay, corresponding to the pre-revised pay scale from which pensioner had retired, as arrived at with reference to the fitment tables annexed to Ministry of Finance, Department of  Expenditure OM No. 1/1/2008-ICdated 30th August, 2008. Hon'ble CAT, Principal Bench, New Delhi vide its common order dated 1.11.2011 in OA No.65512010 and three other connected OAs directed to re-fix the pension of all pre-2006 retirees w.e.f.1.1.2006 based on the Resolution dated 29.8.2008 of the Department of Pension &Pensioners' Welfare and in the light of the observations of Hon'ble CAT in that order.
3. Orders were issued vide this Department's OM of even number dated 28.1.2013for stepping up of pension of pre-2006 pensioners w.e.f. 24.9.2012 to 50% of the minimum of pay in the pay band and grade pay corresponding to pre-revised pay scale from which the pensioner retired. Para 5 of this OM provides that in case the consolidated pension/family pension calculated as per para 4.1 of O.M. No.38/37/08- P&PW (A) dated 1.9.2008 is higher than the pension/family pension calculated in the manner indicated in the O.M. dated 28.1.2013, the same (higher consolidated pension/family pension) will continue to be treated as basic pension/family pension.
4. Subsequently, in compliance of the order dated 1.11.2011 of the Hon'ble CAT,Principal Bench in OA No. 655/2010, order dated 29.4.2013 of Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in WP (C) No. 1535/2012 and order dated 17.3.2015 of Hon'ble Supreme Court
in SLP (C) No. 36148/2013, order were issued vide this Department's OM of even number dated 30.7.2015 that the pension/family pension of all pre - 2006 pensioners/family pensioners may be revised in accordance with this Department's
O.M. No.38/37/08-P&PW(A) dated 28.1.2013 with effect from 1.1.2006 instead of 24.9.2012.
5. In accordance with the order issued in implementation of the recommendation of the 6th CPC, the pension of Government servants retired/retiring on or after 1.1.2006 has been delinked from qualifying service of 33 years. In OA No. 715/2012 filed by Shri. M.O. Inasu, a pre-2006 pensioner, Hon'ble CAT, Emakulam Bench, vide its order dated 16.8.2013 directed that the revised pension w.e.f. 1.1.2006 under para 4.2 of OM dated 1.9.2008 would not be reduced based on the qualifying service of less than 33 years. The appeals filed by Department of Revenue in the Hon'ble High Court of Kerala and in the Hon'ble Supreme Court have also been dismissed. Similar orders have been passed by Hon'ble CATlHigh Court in several other cases also.
6. The matter has been examined in consultation with the Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure). It has now- been decided that the revised consolidated pension of pre-2006 pensioners shall not be lower than 50% of the minimum of the pay in the Pay Band and the grade pay (wherever applicable) corresponding to the prerevised pay scale as per fitment table without pro-rata reduction of pension even if they had qualifying service of less than 33 years at the time of retirement. Accordingly, Para 5 of this Department's OM of even number dated 28.1.2013 would stand deleted.  The arrears of revised pension would be payable with effect from 1.1.2006.
7. 'Ministry of Agriculture, etc. are requested to bring the contents of' these orders to the notice of Controller of Accounts and Accounts Officers and Attached and Subordinate Offices under them for revising the pension of all those pre - 2006 pensioners who had rendered less than 33 years of qualifying service at the time of retirement in the manner as indicated above on top priority. Revised Pension Payment Orders in all these cases may also be issued immediately.
8. All pension disbursing offices of banks are also advised to prominently display these orders on their notice boards for the benefit of pensioners.
9. This issues with the approval of Ministry of Finance, Deptt. of Expenditure vide ID Note No. 2(9)/EV/2015, dated 15.3.2016.
10. Hindi version will follow.
(S~
Deputy Secretary to the Government of India
To
1. All Ministriesl Departments of Government of India. (as per standard mailing list).
2. All SCOV A Members
3. All identified Pensioners Association
Copy to (i) NIC Cell for uploading on the web site of the Department.
(ii) AD (OL), DoPPW for Hindi Version

Rajya Sabha MP writes to Parrikar; lists anomalies in One Rank One Pension scheme

Rajya Sabha MP Rajeev Chandrasekhar on Thursday wrote to Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar listing five anomalies that require attention and revision in order to fully implement One Rank One Pension scheme. He wrote the letter taking note of the terms of reference of one-man judicial committee which stated that it will "examine and make recommendations on references received from the Central government".
The government had on December 14 last year appointed Justice (retd) L Narasimha Reddy as the head of the committee to look into the implementation of OROP. Chandrasekhar said the initiative was a welcome move.
Listing the anomalies, he said equalisation of pensions every five years will bring disparity in pensions and result in senior-ranked officers drawing lesser pension than junior- ranked officers for five years. He said that fixation of pension as per calendar year 2013 would result in past retirees getting less pension of one increment than the soldier retiring today.
The Rajya Sabha MP said that since OROP was approved in the central budget 2014-15, applicability of the same must be 1st April of the same year. Another issue that he raised was denial of OROP to premature retirees from now on.
It is not desirable that pension entitlements under the pension regulations as per Defence Services Regulations be modified through OROP. "It will create a class within a class giving rise to a situation which may not withstand legal scrutiny," he said.

Aggrieved at apathetic attitude of govt, say ex-servicemen

 Monday, February 22, 2016

Tribune News Service

Patiala, February 21

The State Ex-Servicemen Welfare Association (SEWA), Punjab, organised an “Insaf Rally” at the Anaj Mandi here. Various ex-servicemen organisations from Punjab, Haryana and Uttarakhand took part in the rally. The ex-servicemen said they were aggrieved at the apathetic attitude of the government towards One Rank One Pension (OROP) as passed by the Parliament. “Truncated OROP has been implemented denying justice to their rightful demands. There is a huge gap between the minimum and maximum pay and pension of the men in uniform. There is an urgent need to raise the pay and pension of lower rank defence personnel,” the ex-servicemen said. Col Kuldip Singh Grewal (retd), president, State Ex-Servicemen Welfare Association, said after recruitment, soldiers had to undergo military training and professional training before being fit for battle. Even after attaining professional skills, they are equated with Class IV employees in government offices in terms of pay and pension. “Widows of pensioners who after putting in a few years of service are discharged on medical grounds are placed on minimum pension i.e. Rs 3,500, which is too little to sustain their living,” he said. Addressing the ex-servicemen, who came from several parts of North India, Grewal said: “Danger to life is same for all ranks. So, there is a need to raise minimum military service pay of jawans”. Others who spoke on the occasion said the next of kin of those soldiers who attain martyrdom in battle or insurgency should be adequately compensated monetarily in equitable manner irrespective of rank. The anomalies existing in the OROP, which is implemented vide government notification issued in November last, should be corrected without wasting more time to end the ongoing agitations by the ESM community. “Charts notified by the PCDA (Pension) have numerous discrepancies, which need to be rectified,” said the speakers, adding that either the soldiers should be allowed to serve till 60 years of age or their pension should be fixed at the top of the pay band.

Brief of the NJCA meeting held on 19.02.2016 with the Convener, Implementation Cell, Ministry of Finance

NJCA

NATIONAL JOINT COUNCIL OF ACTION,

4, STATE ENTRY ROAD, NEW DELHI-110055

No.NJCA/2016

Dated: 19.02.2016

Dear Comrades,

Sub: Brief of the NJCA meeting held on 19.02.2016 with the Convener, Implementation Cell, Ministry of Finance (Government of India), reg. 7th CPC recommendations and Charter of Demands of the NJCA

A meeting of the NJCA held today with the Convener, Implementation Cell, Ministry of Finance, Shri R.K. Chaturvedi, wherein we discussed and emphasized on all the 26-point Charter of Demands of the NJCA send to the Cabinet Secretary on 10.12.2015.

We agitated the issues of NPS, Minimum Wage, Multiplying Factor, deduction of HRA and all other important issues.

The Convener, Implementation Cell, Shri Chaturvedi, after hearing everybody, said that, he would put-up the issues to the Cabinet Secretary, and hopefully a meeting of the JCA would be held with the Cabinet Secretary and the Empowered Committee shortly within 15 days.

Let us not leave any stone unturned for preparations of the strike.

With Best Wishes!

Comradely yours,
sd/-
(Shiva Gopal Shrma)
Secretary (Staff Side) NC/JCM
&

Government agrees to implement the judgement of CAT

Government has agreed to implement the judgement of the CAT within one month for grant of full Pension to Pre 2006 Pensioners who retired after 10 years of service on superannuation or 20 years of service on Voluntary retirement or absorption in PSU. This commitment was given by the Government Advocate in CAT PB New Delhi during the hearing of the Contempt of Court Case filed by Shri Pratap Narayan & others -vs - Union of India.

TABLE- OROP AND ARREARS UPTO 31 JAN 2016

Sepoy - groupX						Sepoy - groupY
QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears		QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears
15	5961	7145	1184	47988		15	5102	6665	1563	63348
15.5	6071	7145	1074	43529		15.5	5196	6665	1469	59539
16	6182	7145	963	39030		16	5291	6665	1374	55688
16.5	6292	7145	853	34572		16.5	5385	6665	1280	51878
17	6402	7145	743	30114		17	5480	6665	1185	48028
17.5	6513	7145	632	25615		17.5	5574	6698	1124	45556
18	6623	7145	522	21157		18	5669	6698	1029	41705
18.5	6734	7145	411	16658		18.5	5783	6783	1000	40530
19	6844	7145	301	12200		19	5858	6783	925	37490
19.5	6954	7145	191	7741		19.5	5952	6875	923	37409
20	7065	7145	80	3242		20	6047	6875	828	33559
20.5	7065	7145	80	3242		20.5	6047	6875	828	33559
21	7065	7145	80	3242		21	6047	6875	828	33559
21.5	7065	7145	80	3242		21.5	6047	6875	828	33559
22	7065	7145	80	3242		22	6047	6875	828	33559
22.5	7065	7145	80	3242		22.5	6047	6875	828	33559
23	7065	7145	80	3242		23	6047	6875	828	33559
23.5	7065	7145	80	3242		23.5	6047	6875	828	33559
24	7065	7145	80	3242		24	6047	6875	828	33559
24.5	7065	7145	80	3242		24.5	6047	6875	828	33559
25	7065	7145	80	3242		25	6047	6875	828	33559
JAN	7065	7145	80	3242		25.5	6047	7070	1023	41462
26	7065	7145	80	3242		26	6047	7070	1023	41462
26.5	7065	7145	80	3242		26.5	6047	7070	1023	41462
27	7065	7145	80	3242		27	6047	7070	1023	41462
27.5	7175	7145	-30	-1216		27.5	6141	7070	929	37652
28	7285	7145	-140	-5674		28	6235	7070	835	33843
Naik- groupX						Naik- groupY
QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears		QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears
15	5961	8375	2414	97839		15	5156	7170	2014	81627
15.5	6071	8375	2304	93381		15.5	5259	7170	1911	77453
16	6182	8375	2193	88882		16	5362	7170	1808	73278
16.5	6292	8375	2083	84424		16.5	5465	7170	1705	69104
17	6402	8375	1973	79966		17	5568	7170	1602	64929
17.5	6513	8375	1862	75467		17.5	5671	7170	1499	60754
18	6623	8375	1752	71009		18	5774	7170	1396	56580
18.5	6734	8375	1641	66510		18.5	5878	7170	1292	52365
19	6844	8375	1531	62051		19	5981	7170	1189	48190
19.5	6954	8375	1421	57593		19.5	6084	7170	1086	44016
20	7065	8375	1310	53094		20	6187	7170	983	39841
20.5	7154	8375	1221	49487		20.5	6290	7170	880	35666
21	7271	8375	1104	44745		21	6393	7170	777	31492
21.5	7389	8375	986	39963		21.5	6496	7170	674	27317
22	7506	8375	869	35221		22	6599	7170	571	23143
22.5	7506	8375	869	35221		22.5	6599	7170	571	23143
23	7506	8375	869	35221		23	6599	7170	571	23143
23.5	7506	8375	869	35221		23.5	6599	7170	571	23143
24	7506	8525	1019	41300		24	6599	7170	571	23143
24.5	7506	8525	1019	41300		24.5	6599	7170	571	23143
25	7506	8525	1019	41300		25	6599	7170	571	23143
25.5	7506	8525	1019	41300		25.5	6599	7170	571	23143
26	7506	8525	1019	41300		26	6599	7170	571	23143
26.5	7506	8525	1019	41300		26.5	6599	7170	571	23143
27	7506	8525	1019	41300		27	6599	7170	571	23143
27.5	7623	8525	902	36558		27.5	6702	7170	468	18968
28	7740	8525	785	31816		28	6805	7170	365	14793
Havildar- groupX						Havildar- groupY
QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears		QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears
15	6374	8585	2211	89612		15	5301	7550	2249	91152
15.5	6513	8715	2202	89247		15.5	5416	7598	2182	88436
16	6651	8778	2127	86207		16	5531	7598	2067	83776
16.5	6790	8778	1988	80574		16.5	5647	7598	1951	79074
17	6929	8925	1996	80898		17	5762	7598	1836	74413
17.5	7067	8925	1858	75305		17.5	5877	7598	1721	69752
18	7206	8925	1719	69671		18	5992	7655	1663	67401
18.5	7344	8925	1581	64078		18.5	6108	7693	1585	64240
19	7483	9055	1572	63713		19	6223	7693	1470	59579
19.5	7621	9055	1434	58120		19.5	6338	7693	1355	54918
20	7760	9055	1295	52486		20	6453	7795	1342	54391
20.5	7898	9055	1157	46893		20.5	6568	7795	1227	49730
21	8037	9055	1018	41260		21	6684	7795	1111	45029
21.5	8176	9055	879	35626		21.5	6799	7795	996	40368
22	8314	9055	741	30033		22	6914	7795	881	35707
22.5	8453	9280	827	33518		22.5	7029	7795	766	31046
23	8591	9280	689	27925		23	7145	7795	650	26345
23.5	8730	9793	1063	43083		23.5	6290	7795	1505	60998
24	8868	9793	925	37490		24	7375	7808	433	17549
24.5	8868	9793	925	37490		24.5	7375	7808	433	17549
25	8868	9793	925	37490		25	7375	7808	433	17549
25.5	8868	9793	925	37490		25.5	7375	7808	433	17549
26	8868	9793	925	37490		26	7375	7995	620	25129
26.5	8868	9793	925	37490		26.5	7375	7995	620	25129
27	8868	9793	925	37490		27	7375	7995	620	25129
27.5	9007	9793	786	31857		27.5	7490	7995	505	20468
28	9145	9793	648	26263		28	7605	7995	390	15807
Naib Subedar- groupX						Naib Subedar- groupY
QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears		QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears
15	6974	10480	3506	142098		15	6470	8740	2270	92003
15.5	7151	10480	3329	134924		15.5	6632	8740	2108	85437
16	7325	10480	3155	127872		16	6794	8740	1946	78871
16.5	7499	10480	2981	120820		16.5	6955	8740	1785	72346
17	7674	10480	2806	113727		17	7117	8740	1623	65780
17.5	7848	10480	2632	106675		17.5	7279	8740	1461	59214
18	8023	10480	2457	99582		18	7441	8740	1299	52648
18.5	8197	10480	2283	92530		18.5	7602	8740	1138	46123
19	8371	10480	2109	85478		19	7764	8740	976	39557
19.5	8546	10480	1934	78385		19.5	7926	8740	814	32991
20	8720	10480	1760	71333		20	8088	8755	667	27034
20.5	8895	10480	1585	64240		20.5	8249	8755	506	20508
21	9069	10480	1411	57188		21	8411	8853	442	17914
21.5	9243	10480	1237	50136		21.5	8573	8934	361	14631
22	9418	10527	1109	44948		22	8735	9005	270	10943
22.5	9592	10682	1090	44178		22.5	8896	9338	442	17914
23	9767	10804	1037	42030		23	9058	9338	280	11348
23.5	9941	10971	1030	41746		23.5	9220	9338	118	4783
24	10115	11138	1023	41462		24	9382	9429	47	1905
24.5	10290	11138	848	34369		24.5	9543	9652	109	4418
25	10464	11138	674	27317		25	9705	9733	28	1135
25.5	10639	11205	566	22940		25.5	9887	9946	59	2391
26	10813	11205	392	15888		26	10029	10405	376	15239
26.5	10987	11261	274	11105		26.5	10190	10415	225	9119
27	11162	11261	99	4012		27	10352	10415	63	2553
27.5	11336	11418	82	3323		27.5	10514	10577	63	2553
28	11510	11958	448	18157		28	10675	10742	67	2716
Subedar- groupX						Subedar- groupY
QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears		QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears
15	7943	10923	2980	120779		15	7255	10923	3668	148664
15.5	8141	10923	2782	112754		15.5	7436	10923	3487	141328
16	8340	11045	2705	109634		16	7618	10923	3305	133952
16.5	8539	11045	2506	101568		16.5	7799	10923	3124	126616
17	8737	11150	2413	97799		17	7980	11150	3170	128480
17.5	8936	11615	2679	108580		17.5	8162	11150	2988	121104
18	9134	11615	2481	100555		18	8343	11150	2807	113768
18.5	9333	11615	2282	92489		18.5	8525	11150	2625	106391
19	9531	11615	2084	84465		19	8706	11150	2444	99055
19.5	9730	11615	1885	76399		19.5	8887	11150	2263	91719
20	9929	11615	1686	68334		20	9069	11150	2081	84343
20.5	10127	11615	1488	60309		20.5	9250	11150	1900	77007
21	10326	11615	1289	52243		21	9431	11150	1719	69671
21.5	10524	11615	1091	44218		21.5	9613	11150	1537	62295
22	10723	11615	892	36153		22	9794	11150	1356	54959
22.5	10921	11615	694	28128		22.5	9975	11150	1175	47623
23	11120	11615	495	20062		23	10157	11150	993	40246
23.5	11318	11615	297	12037		23.5	10338	11150	812	32910
24	11517	11615	98	3972		24	10520	11150	630	25534
24.5	11716	11716	0	0		24.5	10701	11150	449	18198
25	11914	12820	906	36720		25	10882	11150	268	10862
25.5	12113	12820	707	28655		25.5	11064	11150	86	3486
26	12311	12820	509	20630		26	11245	11427	182	7376
26.5	12510	12820	310	12564		26.5	11426	11476	50	2027
27	12708	13085	377	15280		27	11608	11859	251	10173
27.5	12907	13085	178	7214		27.5	11789	11859	70	2837
28	13105	13215	110	4458		28	11970	12268	298	12078
28.5	13105	13215	110	4458		28.5	13105	12268	-837	-33924
29	13105	13415	310	12564		29	13105	12268	-837	-33924
29.5	13105	13415	310	12564		29.5	13105	12460	-645	-26142
30	13105	13643	538	21805		30	13105	12690	-415	-16820
Subedar Major-GroupX						Subedar Major-GroupY
QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears		QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears
15	8237	11770	3533	143192		15	7446	11305	3859	156405
15.5	8443	11952	3509	142220		15.5	7632	11480	3848	155959
16	8649	12134	3485	141247		16	7818	11654	3836	155473
16.5	8855	12322	3467	140518		16.5	8004	11834	3830	155230
17	9060	12509	3449	139788		17	8190	12014	3824	154987
17.5	9266	12702	3436	139261		17.5	8377	12200	3823	154946
18	9472	12895	3423	138734		18	8563	12385	3822	154906
18.5	9678	12895	3217	130385		18.5	8749	12385	3636	147367
19	9884	12895	3011	122036		19	8935	12385	3450	139829
19.5	10090	12895	2805	113687		19.5	9121	12385	3264	132290
20	10296	12895	2599	105337		20	9307	12385	3078	124751
20.5	10502	12895	2393	96988		20.5	9493	12385	2892	117213
21	10708	12960	2252	91274		21	9680	12385	2705	109634
21.5	10914	12960	2046	82924		21.5	9866	12385	2519	102095
22	11120	12960	1840	74575		22	10052	12385	2333	94556
22.5	11325	12960	1635	66267		22.5	10238	12385	2147	87018
23	11531	12960	1429	57917		23	10424	12385	1961	79479
23.5	11737	12960	1223	49568		23.5	10610	12565	1955	79236
24	11943	12960	1017	41219		24	10798	12565	1767	71617
24.5	12149	12960	811	32870		24.5	10983	12565	1582	64118
25	12355	13068	713	28898		25	11168	12565	1397	56620
25.5	12561	13068	507	20549		25.5	11355	12565	1210	49041
26	12767	13068	301	12200		26	11541	12565	1024	41503
26.5	12973	13068	95	3850		26.5	11727	12565	838	33964
27	13179	13557	378	15320		27	11913	12565	652	26426
27.5	13385	13557	172	6971		27.5	12099	12575	476	19292
28	13590	13590	0	0		28	12285	12575	290	11754
28.5	13590	13795	205	8309		28.5	12285	12575	290	11754
29	13590	13990	400	16212		29	12285	13045	760	30803
29.5	13590	13990	400	16212		29.5	12285	13045	760	30803
30	13590	14140	550	22292		30	12285	13045	760	30803
30.5	13590	14348	758	30722		30.5	12285	13045	760	30803
31	13590	14348	758	30722		31	12285	13045	760	30803
31.5	13590	14348	758	30722		31.5	12285	13045	760	30803
32	13590	14348	758	30722		32	12285	13045	760	30803
32.5	13590	14348	758	30722		32.5	12285	13045	760	30803
>+33	13590	14348	758	30722		>+33	12285	13045	760	30803
HONY LT						HONY CAPT
QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears		QS	NOW	OROP	Diff	Arrears
15	9373	11770	2397	97150		15	9785	12976	3191	129331
15.5	9608	11952	2344	95002		15.5	10030	13177	3147	127548
16	9842	12134	2292	92895		16	10275	13377	3102	125724
16.5	10076	12322	2246	91030		16.5	10519	13584	3065	124224
17	10310	12509	2199	89125		17	10764	13790	3026	122644
17.5	10545	12702	2157	87423		17.5	11088	14003	2915	118145
18	10779	12895	2116	85761		18	11253	14216	2963	120090
18.5	11013	12895	1882	76277		18.5	11498	14436	2938	119077
19	11248	12895	1647	66753		19	11742	14655	2913	118064
19.5	11482	12921	1439	58323		19.5	11987	14882	2895	117334
20	11716	13117	1401	56783		20	12232	15108	2876	116564
20.5	11951	13320	1369	55486		20.5	12476	15342	2866	116159
21	12185	13522	1337	54189		21	12721	15575	2854	115673
21.5	12419	13731	1312	53175		21.5	12965	15575	2610	105783
22	12654	13940	1286	52122		22	13210	15575	2365	95853
22.5	12888	14156	1268	51392		22.5	13455	15575	2120	85924
23	13122	14371	1249	50622		23	13699	15575	1876	76034
23.5	13357	14593	1236	50095		23.5	13944	15945	2001	81101
24	13591	14815	1224	49609		24	14189	15945	1756	71171
24.5	13825	15044	1219	49406		24.5	14433	15945	1512	61281
25	14060	15273	1213	49163		25	14678	15945	1267	51352
25.5	14294	15273	979	39679		25.5	14922	15945	1023	41462
26	14528	15273	745	30195		26	15167	15945	778	31532
26.5	14763	15273	510	20670		26.5	15412	15945	533	21602
27	14997	15336	339	13740		27	15656	16201	545	22089
27.5	15231	15821	590	23913		27.5	15901	16201	300	12159
28	15465	16090	625	25331		28	16145	17010	865	35058
28.5	15465	16090	625	25331		28.5	16145	17010	865	35058
29	15465	16090	625	25331		29	16145	17010	865	35058
29.5	15465	16090	625	25331		29.5	16145	17010	865	35058
30	15465	16090	625	25331		30	16145	17010	865	35058
30.5	15465	16090	625	25331		30.5	16145	17010	865	35058
31	15465	16090	625	25331		31	16145	17010	865	35058
31.5	15465	16090	625	25331		31.5	16145	17010	865	35058
32	15465	16090	625	25331		32	16145	17010	865	35058
32.5	15465	16090	625	25331		32.5	16145	17010	865	35058
>+33	15465	16160	695	28168		>+33	16145	17010	865	35058

Prepared by HFO MP SHARMA