tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post6503606097403677795..comments2024-03-22T04:20:19.149+05:30Comments on . : CAT PB GRANTS 3MONTHS TO UOI FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF JUDGEMENT IN OA 655/2010M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comBlogger49125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-65469085958477028852015-07-25T20:35:28.798+05:302015-07-25T20:35:28.798+05:30Just now read following flash on www.rscws.com
...Just now read following flash on www.rscws.com <br /><br />Approval of MOF has been given for implementation of orders of SC (dated 17-3-2015) & CAT (dated 1-11-2011) reg Modified parity wef 1-1-2006. Orders are likely to be issued in 2 to 3 days. Heartiest congratulations to all the affected Pensioners and thanks to all those who worked hard to win this battle at various stages - both in and out side the courts.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08186574343545660777noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-51401910437190767272015-07-17T16:42:32.005+05:302015-07-17T16:42:32.005+05:30Sir,
As per the verdict of Hon. Supreme Court of ...Sir,<br /><br />As per the verdict of Hon. Supreme Court of India, the period of 3 months to implement the same has already been over, what is the action from Government side for its implementation Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/08186574343545660777noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-58960436546238625222015-02-04T14:26:36.972+05:302015-02-04T14:26:36.972+05:30Sir,
I have put-in 11 years service in central gov...Sir,<br />I have put-in 11 years service in central government and later in 2002 absorbed in autonomous body, where there is no pension. I'm getting pro-rata pension in tune of 22/66, i.e, 30% of the pension. Am I eligible for full pension?Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-5708821590902239842015-01-01T19:10:40.508+05:302015-01-01T19:10:40.508+05:30Dear Sir,
If the SlP is decided in favor of the pe...Dear Sir,<br />If the SlP is decided in favor of the pensioners,you will get the arrears from 01/01/2006 on full parity basis along with DA.M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-30725067605758989602014-12-30T12:55:07.299+05:302014-12-30T12:55:07.299+05:30Dear Mr. menon,
I voluntarily retired from IIT in ...Dear Mr. menon,<br />I voluntarily retired from IIT in the scale of 3700-5700, in 1990, as assistant professor. As per SCPC, assistant prof were put PB3. My basic pension, was enhanced from 12,517 to 20,388. No doubt I am happy about the big rise. But I was told by IIT in PB4. I would like to know how it happened.<br />More importantly, assuming favourable verdict from SC, will I get the same rise from 1-1-06 along with DA on the same?Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02150597356772658028noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-51215653223598236032014-12-30T12:20:15.857+05:302014-12-30T12:20:15.857+05:30Thank you Mr Menon for clearly defining the parame...Thank you Mr Menon for clearly defining the parameters of full pension for 20 years+. <br />can you please take the trouble of clarifying whether the case of full pension is par and parcel of the case pending in the supreme court? In other words, assuming SC will dismiis the SLP, do we , the pre 2006 pensioners get both benefits: namely, arrears from 1-1-06 for whatever we got from 24-92012, and full pension from 24-9-2008 ?Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/02150597356772658028noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-963296897286253262014-07-07T21:34:49.812+05:302014-07-07T21:34:49.812+05:30Dear Sir,
The judgement in OA 655/2010 is for impl...Dear Sir,<br />The judgement in OA 655/2010 is for implementation of cabinet resolution OM dated 29/08/2008 which excludes PBOR.Hence PBOR is not likely to be benefited by this judgement.M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-79068480963879258792014-07-07T16:57:08.534+05:302014-07-07T16:57:08.534+05:30Sir, I retired from the Army after completion of 1...Sir, I retired from the Army after completion of 16 years of service. Since my service is less than 20 years. Please let me know whether the persons who's service is less than 20 years will be benefitted of this Case OA 655/2010 or not. Ajay<br />Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-66783907523101004832014-06-20T14:38:59.682+05:302014-06-20T14:38:59.682+05:30DEAR SIR
I RETIRED AS SGT FROM IAF AFTER 15 YEARS...DEAR SIR<br /><br />I RETIRED AS SGT FROM IAF AFTER 15 YEARS OF SERVICE ON 30 SEPTEMBER 1981 BUT GETTING PENSION OF CPL AS I DID NOT COMPLETE 10 MONTHS AS SGT<br />ANY WAY HOW MUCH TOTAL PENSION I WILL GET AFTER OROPAnonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-69516484172896828762014-06-08T11:44:48.143+05:302014-06-08T11:44:48.143+05:30Dear mr.menon, Thanks for responding. Let us just ...Dear mr.menon, Thanks for responding. Let us just take a re-look. The judgement delivered in OA 655/2010 has interalia a relief of 50% pension for pre2006 pensioners with 20 yrs service at par with those of post2006.Now, the govt have committed before CAT that the said judgement will be honored. I think it is basic in law that the honoring judgement means implementing it in full and not in part. You may be aware that you had also,in one of your earlier replies to me, had spoken of this point. So, with the govt having given such an assurance to CAT, dont you think that those 3 slps in SC automatically lose whatever legal standing it has, of course subject to how effectively the above position is presented before the SC in case the govt not withdrawing the same on their own? <br />I believe your studied clarification for the above will clear my doubt once for all; please expedite your comments/clarifications.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14492146045254987344noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-61645809000698579282014-06-08T10:56:10.602+05:302014-06-08T10:56:10.602+05:30Dear Sir,
There is no link between OA2165/2011 &am...Dear Sir,<br />There is no link between OA2165/2011 & 3SLPs 36148-50/2013.The judgement in WP(C) 2348-50/2012 by DHC is challenged in 3SLPs.Your attention is drawn that the judgement by CAT PB in OA655/2010 & other 3 linked cases was challenged by UOI in DHC by WP(C) 1535/2012 & other 3 linked cases WP(c) 2348-50/2012.The clever UOI has challenged WP(c) 1535/2012 separately as SLP ,Review petition & curative petition.Now at last they have challenged WP(C) 2348-50/2012 in SC by 3 SLPs(c) 36148-50/2013<br />M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-15651677942646940742014-06-06T12:08:36.587+05:302014-06-06T12:08:36.587+05:30Besides all i have stated above, what really drive...Besides all i have stated above, what really drives me dizzy about the whole process is that there is already a stand alone judgement vide OA 2461/2012 allowing 50%(full)pension for pre2006 pensioners with 20 yrs or more service which has in fact been highlighted by you in an exclusive space under the caption" 50% pension for 20 yrs service"over the communication box in this dedicated blog site. Now, interestingly, OA 1165/2011is also being heard in PB CAT for the same relief of full(50%)pension on the same grounds though the said relief is also granted by CAT in OA 2461/2012 and the direction was already issued to govt to implement the order within 3 months as I see from your site. Is it not confusing that an OA is still being heard in cat while there is a clear judgement already delivered by the same PB CAT in a past OA of a similar nature with the same grouds?<br />Would you kindly clarify for the benefit of other readers like me also, the legal aspects that have led to this intriguing situation?Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14492146045254987344noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-20845469566523546322014-06-04T22:37:23.170+05:302014-06-04T22:37:23.170+05:30dear mr.menon, thanks for reply. In your earlier c...dear mr.menon, thanks for reply. In your earlier clarification you had stated that one of the reliefs vide 655/2010 is full pension for pre2006 pensioners with 20 yrs service; so naturally since govt has now assured cat that they will honour the judgement, i thought that the govt is absolutely bound to give the benefit of full pension to pre2006 pensioners with 20 yrs service. But now i am confused that you are saying something to the effect that the prospective judgements in some other pending cases may go against the said full pension. in fact you've also indicated that full pension has already been ordered in our favour vide OA2461/2012 as has been highlighted by you over the communication box. Honestly, I am more confused than ever before! I am at a loss to understand how a judgement given in one case will be affected by that of the other case of similar nature? Above all, is it legally viable to entertain any further case of similar nature while there is a clear judgement of a past case of a a similar nature as in the instant case?! Shall i at best infer that the judgement to be given by sc in the 3 pending SLPs will be final in this regard? Please clarify.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14492146045254987344noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-30375216452612924172014-06-04T21:44:09.024+05:302014-06-04T21:44:09.024+05:30Dear Mr.Swamy,
There are many cases of similar nat...Dear Mr.Swamy,<br />There are many cases of similar nature pending in many courts & these are not going to affect the implementaion of court order in OA 655/2010 & 3 SLP pending in SC ,Which may affect the 50 % pension after 20 years for pre-2006 pensioners if the judgement is against pensioners. I hope I have already made it clear this points to you.<br /><br /> M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-40731518646006859042014-06-04T12:14:38.202+05:302014-06-04T12:14:38.202+05:30Dear mr.menon, since i doubt if my earlier query d...Dear mr.menon, since i doubt if my earlier query didnt get reflected here, i am once again posting the same for your clafification.<br />would you kindly clarify as to why OA1165/2011(as is shown by mr.kanujia in his latest compilation of court cases)is still not disposed of in favour of the applicant granting relief of full pension for 20 yrs, since the same relief is already granted vide judgement given for OA 2461/2012 and more recently by way of the assurance given by the govt to honour the verdict given for 655/2010?Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14492146045254987344noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-53668256110426927732014-06-03T16:09:13.279+05:302014-06-03T16:09:13.279+05:30sir ,
i havve got 20 yers services and rtd on 200...sir ,<br /> i havve got 20 yers services and rtd on 2005 nov , my basic pension is 6453/- what will be my OROP ?how you are calculating the way ,pl give replay to ragu2003@gmail.com <br />thanking you <br />ragu ESMAhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/00153145349085638218noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-70076112338031672202014-06-03T10:45:02.993+05:302014-06-03T10:45:02.993+05:30Dear mr.menon,
Please refer to one shir.subra'...Dear mr.menon,<br />Please refer to one shir.subra's posting in the communication box wherein it is stated that the OA 1165/2011 is scheduled to be heard in PB CAT next month.I see from the latest status of the pending court cases, that this case also pertains to grant of full pension for pre2006 pensioners with 20 yrs service.<br />Would you please throw some light on the continued need for hearing this case since the relief sought(50%pension) is already granted by the PB CAT in a similar case vide OA 2461/2012 as has been highlighted by you in an exclusive box over the communication box? Moreover, the UOI have also submitted before the PB CAT that they will honour the judgement given in OA 655/2010 that interalia includes the same provision of 50% pension for pre2006 pensioners!<br />Kindly clarify please.Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14492146045254987344noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-79516777793146728552014-05-27T14:03:35.079+05:302014-05-27T14:03:35.079+05:30Dear Sir,
I assume that you belong to group y &...Dear Sir,<br />I assume that you belong to group y & your expected pension under OROP is likely to be approximately 7020M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-4744346086189828342014-05-27T13:48:11.687+05:302014-05-27T13:48:11.687+05:30Dear Mr. Menon I got retirement from the IAF w.e.f...Dear Mr. Menon I got retirement from the IAF w.e.f. 28.02.1998 after completing 21 years service in the rank of Sgt. At present my basic pension is 6684/- What will be my pension after revision of the pension.s k meharhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12466748625517389309noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-49335343486270543962014-05-25T21:56:55.157+05:302014-05-25T21:56:55.157+05:30Dear Sir,
The CAT PB judgement is only for pension...Dear Sir,<br />The CAT PB judgement is only for pensioners of 20 years & above qualifying service.Hence you will not be benefited by that.There case pending in CAT PB by which you will be benefited if the judgement is in favour.It reads as given below.<br /><br />O.A.No.2165/2011 (K.Srinivasan and Ors. Vs U.O.I) and OA No. 247/2012 (S.B.Roy and Ors Vs U.O.I.)<br />(i) grant of full pension after completion of 20 years service in case of Voluntary Retirement;<br />(ii) grant of full pension after completion of 10 years of service in case of retirement on superannuation; <br />(iii) grant of full pension after completion of 10 years of service in case of absorption in government undertakings/autonomous bodies.<br />M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-61354731264878516882014-05-25T13:13:24.088+05:302014-05-25T13:13:24.088+05:30Dear Sir,
I got absobed in REC on 1-7-79 in pay sc...Dear Sir,<br />I got absobed in REC on 1-7-79 in pay scale of Rs 500-900,which has been revised as 9300+4200.My total service in Def Accounts Deptt was 15 years,7 months & 13 days.In PSU no benefit of previous service was given.DAD has brought down my pension to Minimum viz Rs 3,500/-.Shall I be benifitted with CAT order of 50% of Minimum corresponding Pay+grade pay ,which is applicable on completion of 20 years service, if not then what will be my pro-rata pension after rendering15 years,7 months & 13 days service in DAD.<br />S.K.SharmaSuresh Kumar Sharmahttps://www.blogger.com/profile/04165136170708984461noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-9873750095733480362014-05-24T22:32:42.326+05:302014-05-24T22:32:42.326+05:30Dear Sir,
If modified parity is implemented you wi...Dear Sir,<br />If modified parity is implemented you will get a basic pension of Rs.12600 only where as if full parity is implemented you are likely to get a basic pension of Rs.14415.This calculation is made as per the fitment table as applicable to post 2006 pensioners on full parity basis.you are now getting not even 50% of the minimum of the pay in the pay band 25200/2=12600M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-24122002260509094672014-05-24T21:58:19.581+05:302014-05-24T21:58:19.581+05:30Dear Sir,
If modified parity is implemented you wi...Dear Sir,<br />If modified parity is implemented you will get a basic pension of Rs.6750 only where as if full parity is implemented you are likely to get a basic pension of Rs.7170M B Chandran Menon. M.com.,AIII,DMEhttps://www.blogger.com/profile/12408807503177898470noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-79136102609715110272014-05-24T17:58:14.266+05:302014-05-24T17:58:14.266+05:30Respected Menon ji,
Thanks
Sir, I had mentioned...Respected Menon ji,<br /><br />Thanks<br /><br />Sir, I had mentioned only starting scale of may post. However my basic pay on 01/01/1998 was Rs. 5450/-. Qualifying service year were 22 on 01/01/1998. Kindly advise.<br /><br />Kind regards.<br />Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-7817212952570625353.post-81697861165693658412014-05-24T15:08:45.239+05:302014-05-24T15:08:45.239+05:30Dear Sir,
I joined service on 14.2.1979 and after...Dear Sir,<br /><br />I joined service on 14.2.1979 and after 26 years, 3 months service, I retired from Ministry of DONER (development of north east region) on 3.6.2005. My basic pay was Rs. 11950 in S19 pay scale 10000-15200. Average 10 months' emolument (BP + 50% Dearness Pay )was Rs. 17438. My pension was fixed at Rs. 8191 not having 33 years service..<br /><br />My revised pension after 6CPC is Rs. 12342. The revised scale is Rs. 15600-39100 + 6600 grade pay. Minimum of the pay scale is Rs. 25200.<br /><br />So, I am getting pension at 50% of the minimum of the revised pay scale, without any fitment benefit. Please advise with correct calculation on the basis of CAT judgement.<br /><br />MITHRAN<br /><br />Anonymoushttps://www.blogger.com/profile/03959837931138737233noreply@blogger.com